Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop in Fort Collins, CO
Display case in a Chinese bakery — illustrative photo
Cake display cases with cakes and pastries in Brastads Bageri 4 — illustrative photo
Cake display cases with cakes and pastries in Brastads Bageri 2 — illustrative photo

Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop

Your guide to this pie shop on 4212 S College Ave #101, Fort Collins — hours, map, menu and directions.

Pie shop
Get directions (970) 775-3321 See the menu

Opening hours

 
Mountain Time
Opening hours have not been published for this bakery yet. Call (970) 775-3321 to check today's hours. Know the hours? Send them to us.
Tap for directions

4212 S College Ave #101, Fort Collins, CO 80525

Google Maps Apple Maps Waze Bing Maps
Address4212 S College Ave #101, Fort Collins, CO 80525
Phone(970) 775-3321
StylePie shop
CountyLarimer County
Time zoneMountain Time
From city center2.6 mi south

About Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop

Set at 4212 S College Ave #101 (80525), Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop is a pie shop about 2.6 mi south of central Fort Collins.

Our Fort Collins directory counts 52 bakeries in total, which works out to one bakery per 3,287 residents. The closest neighbour on our map is Daddy Cakes Bakery, 0.3 mi away.

We have not been able to confirm a full weekly schedule for Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop yet, so calling ahead at (970) 775-3321 is the safest bet. Bakeries often sell out of popular items by early afternoon.

What to order

Typical items at a pie shop like this one — the bakery's own selection may differ.

Full menu

Fruit pies

  • Strawberry rhubarb pieSweet strawberries balanced by tart rhubarb in a pink, jammy filling; a short-season spring favorite.
  • Dutch apple pieSingle-crust apple pie heaped with a buttery brown sugar and oat crumble in place of the top crust.
  • Mixed berry pieRaspberries, blackberries and blueberries baked together into a deep purple, tangy-sweet filling under a vented double crust brushed with cream.
  • Blackberry cobbler pieWild-style blackberries under a tender biscuit-like topping, rustic and juicy with a slight seedy crunch.

Cream & custard pies

  • Chocolate cream pieCooked chocolate pudding filling, smooth and dense, chilled in a cookie crumb crust with whipped topping.
  • Butterscotch cream pieBrown sugar and butter custard with a deep caramel flavor, topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream.
  • Coconut cream pieRich coconut custard in a baked crust, topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes.
  • Banana cream pieLayers of sliced banana and vanilla pastry cream in a flaky crust under a cloud of whipped cream.

Southern & heritage pies

  • Hoosier sugar cream pieIndiana's creamy, eggless custard of cream and sugar dusted with nutmeg, sweet and gently set.
  • Shoofly piePennsylvania Dutch molasses pie with a wet, gooey bottom layer and a crumbly spiced topping.
  • Classic pecan pieToasted pecan halves set in a gooey brown sugar and corn syrup filling inside a buttery crust.
  • Chocolate bourbon pecanPecan pie enriched with dark chocolate chunks and a splash of bourbon for depth and warmth.

Photos

All photos
Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop in Fort Collins, CO
Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop
Display case in a Chinese bakery — illustrative photo
Illustrative photo
Cake display cases with cakes and pastries in Brastads Bageri 4 — illustrative photo
Illustrative photo
Cake display cases with cakes and pastries in Brastads Bageri 2 — illustrative photo
Illustrative photo

Visitor reviews

Write a review
No reviews yet. Been to Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop? Your review helps other people decide — be the first to write one.

Questions about Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop

What are Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop's hours?
We have not verified a weekly schedule for Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop yet. Call (970) 775-3321 to confirm before visiting.
Where is Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop located?
Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop is at 4212 S College Ave #101, Fort Collins, CO 80525. Tap the map on this page to open turn-by-turn directions.
What is the phone number for Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop?
The listed phone number is (970) 775-3321.
What should I order at Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop?
As a pie shop, typical picks include Strawberry rhubarb pie, Dutch apple pie, Chocolate cream pie, and Butterscotch cream pie. See the full menu page for more.
What other bakeries are near Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop?
Nearby options include Daddy Cakes Bakery (0.3 mi), The Pig and the Plow (0.3 mi), and LaMar's Donuts and Coffee (0.3 mi).

Bakeries near Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop

Daddy Cakes Bakery
Daddy Cakes Bakery140 Boardwalk Dr Unit J, Fort Collins
0.3 mi awayCake shop
The Pig and the Plow
The Pig and the Plow140 Boardwalk Dr, Fort Collins
0.3 mi awayBakery
LaMar's Donuts and Coffee
LaMar's Donuts and Coffee140 Boardwalk Dr, Fort Collins
0.3 mi awayDonut shop
Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels250 E Harmony Rd, Fort Collins
0.4 mi awayBagel shop
Krispy Kreme
Krispy Kreme4624 South Mason Street, Fort Collins
0.5 mi awayDonut shop
Panera Bread
Panera Bread3700 S College Ave, Fort Collins
0.5 mi awayArtisan bread bakery
Butter Cream Cupcakery
Butter Cream Cupcakery3663 S College Ave, Fort Collins
0.6 mi awayCupcake shop
Great Harvest Bread Co.
Great Harvest Bread Co.3600 S College Ave, Fort Collins
0.6 mi awayArtisan bread bakery
All bakeries in Fort Collins52 bakeries on one map Pie ShopsFind more near you Open right nowBakeries open at this moment near you